hourglass, clock, schedule, minutes, money, glass, antiquity, hourglass, hourglass, hourglass, hourglass, hourglass. Term loans, matched to what they buy: amortisation compared against asset life
Photo by fernandozhiminaicela on Pixabay

Features

Term loans, matched to what they buy: amortisation compared against asset life

Term loans are the plainest instrument in business finance, so the errors are of shape: how amortisation behaves, and matching a term to what it buys.

A term loan is the plainest instrument in business finance: a fixed sum, paid out once, repaid on a schedule, over a defined period. There is very little to it, which is why the mistakes made with one are almost always mistakes of shape rather than of pricing.

The design decision that matters is how long the loan runs against how long the thing it buys will last. Get that wrong and you will still be paying for equipment you have already scrapped, or straining every month to fund something that should have been spread out.

What to take away

  • Match the repayment period to the working life of what you are buying. That single choice does most of the work.
  • Early payments are mostly interest, so refinancing repeatedly resets you to the expensive end of the schedule.
  • Test the payment against your worst recent month, not your average one.

How amortization actually behaves

Each payment on an ordinary term loan does two jobs: it covers interest accrued on the balance still outstanding, and it reduces that balance.

Payment split over loan life

Early payments

Balance outstanding
Large
Interest portion
Most of payment
Principal portion
Little
Total payment
Identical

Later payments

Balance outstanding
Small
Interest portion
Small part
Principal portion
More
Total payment
Identical

Because interest is charged on what remains, the split moves over the life of the loan. Early on, the balance is large, so most of the payment is interest and little of it reduces the debt. Later, the balance is smaller, so more of each payment goes to principal. The payment can be identical throughout while its composition changes completely.

Three practical consequences follow.

Progress feels slow at first. Owners who check the balance a year in are frequently surprised at how little it has moved. That is the arithmetic, not an error.

Refinancing restarts the pattern. Moving to a new loan puts you back at the front of a new schedule, where payments are again mostly interest. Refinancing can still be the right decision, but the comparison has to be made on total cost from here to the end, not on the monthly payment.

Extra payments are worth most early. Where the loan is amortising and prepayment is permitted, money put in early removes interest that would otherwise accrue for the whole remaining term.

Term length pulls in two directions

Stretching the term lowers the payment and raises the total cost, because the balance stays outstanding longer. Shortening it does the reverse, and adds strain in every month.

Term length trade-offs

Longer term

Monthly payment
Lower
Total cost
Higher
Monthly strain
Less
Balance outstanding
Longer

Shorter term

Monthly payment
Higher
Total cost
Lower
Monthly strain
More
Balance outstanding
Shorter

Neither is virtuous by itself. A payment that is comfortable in a good month and impossible in a bad one is not cheaper in any sense that matters. A business that fails a covenant or misses a payment has bought a much larger problem than the interest it saved.

The rule that resolves it is not about affordability at all. It is about matching.

Match the loan to the life of what it buys

Debt should retire at roughly the pace the thing it financed loses its usefulness.

Match loan to asset life

What are you buying?

Yes

Short-lived asset -> short term

No

Long-lived asset -> longer term

  • Financing a short-lived asset over a long termleaves you making payments on equipment you have replaced, and it consumes the borrowing capacity you need for the replacement.
  • Financing a long-lived asset over a very short termputs avoidable pressure on cash flow for something that will earn for a decade.
  • Financing working capital with a term loanis a different question entirely. Working capital needs revolve: they rise and fall with the trading cycle, and a facility that can be drawn and repaid usually fits that shape better than a lump sum repaid on a fixed schedule.
  • Financing lossesis not financing at all. A term loan taken to cover a shortfall that has no plan behind it converts an operating problem into an operating problem with a monthly payment.

Write down what you are buying, how long it will earn, and what you will do at the end of its life. If the loan outlasts the answer, change the loan.

A worked comparison: a five-year asset on two terms

Take an invented machine that will earn for five years, financed with an invented 100,000 at a fixed two-thirds of a percent a month, repaid in equal monthly payments. The figures are for the arithmetic, not a quote.

TermMonthly paymentTotal interestStill owed when the machine is retired after five years
Five years, 60 paymentsabout 2,028about 21,700nothing
Ten years, 120 paymentsabout 1,213about 45,600about 59,800

The ten-year loan looks cheaper every month, but when the machine stops earning, about 59,800 is still owed on it, and replacing the machine means borrowing again on top of that balance. Over its full life the longer loan also costs more than twice the interest. That is the gap between amortisation and asset life, in numbers.

SBA rules build the same idea into the 7(a) program. The term is the shortest appropriate one given the borrower's ability to repay, and it is ten years or less unless the loan finances or refinances real estate or equipment with a useful life exceeding ten years; real estate can run to a maximum of 25 years, including extensions.

Fixed and variable, and what a variable rate is tied to

A fixed rate is set at the outset and stays there. A variable rate moves with a published reference rate plus a margin agreed with the lender.

Variable rate questions

  • Which reference rate it follows
  • What margin sits on top
  • How often it resets
  • Whether there is a floor or cap
  • What the reference has done historically
  • Whether payment or term adjusts

If you are offered a variable rate, establish four things: which reference it follows, what margin sits on top, how often it resets, and whether there is a floor or a cap. Then find out what the reference has done historically, because that is the part the lender will not editorialise about.

The Federal Reserve publishes current and historical figures for widely used reference rates in its selected interest rates release, including the bank prime loan rate, which the release describes as one of several base rates used by banks to price short-term business loans. That is the sort of source to check yourself rather than take second hand.

Also establish what happens mechanically when the reference moves. Some agreements adjust the payment; others hold the payment and adjust the term or the final balance. Those feel very different in a business with a tight monthly cycle.

Balloons assume something about the future

Some term loans amortize over a long notional period but fall due much earlier, leaving a large final payment. That structure lowers the payment and defers the problem.

Balloon loan structure

  1. Start
    Loan drawn, amortised over long notional period
  2. During term
    Lower payments, problem deferred
  3. Balloon date
    Large final payment falls due
  4. Refinancing
    Tested in unknown credit conditions

The assumption inside it is that you will be able to refinance when the balloon arrives. That assumption gets tested at a moment you do not choose, in credit conditions you cannot predict, with whatever your accounts look like then.

If an offer contains a balloon, make the plan explicit at the outset: what refinances it, what happens if refinancing is not available, and whether the asset can be sold to clear it.

Security, and what it commits

A secured term loan is backed by collateral, which may be the asset being financed or a broader claim over business assets. Secured lending is usually cheaper, because the lender's exposure is lower.

Security and release checks

  • What the security covers
  • Whether it extends to later assets
  • What triggers release
  • Confirm release after repayment
  • Read personal guarantee separately
  • Government guarantee changes lender's exposure

Establish what the security actually covers, whether it extends to assets acquired later, and what has to happen for it to be released. A filing left in place after a debt is repaid is a routine and avoidable obstacle to your next piece of financing, so confirm the release rather than assuming it. In the US that filing is the UCC-1 financing statement, and the release is a termination statement under section 9-513 of the Uniform Commercial Code, which the secured party must send or file within 20 days after it receives an authenticated demand from you once nothing is secured.

Expect a personal guarantee to be requested for a small business, and read it as its own document. Where a government guarantee sits behind a loan, that changes the lender's exposure and not yours, which is set out in SBA loans.

Size the loan from a real list

Borrow the amount the purpose needs, not the amount you are offered.

Build the loan figure

  • Item, delivery, installation
  • Building work and training
  • Tax and included licenses or software
  • Working capital until it earns
  • Then borrow slightly more than the list

Build the figure from a written list, not a round number. Include the item, delivery, installation, building work, and training. Then add tax, included licenses or software, and working capital to operate it until it earns.

Costs that arrive alongside a purchase can turn a correctly sized loan into an undersized one. The Small Business Administration's guide to calculating startup costs is a reasonable free framework for assembling that list.

Then borrowing slightly more than the list, deliberately, is often wiser than borrowing exactly the list and discovering a gap. What is rarely wise is taking the maximum offered because it was offered.

Stress-test the payment before you sign

Run the proposed payment against your actual trading history rather than a forecast.

Stress-test before signing

  1. Take worst three consecutive months
  2. Check payment would have been made
  3. Ask what must be true again
  4. Decide action at first sign of trouble
  5. Talk to lender before a missed payment

Take your worst three consecutive months from the last couple of years and check whether the payment would have been made without difficulty. Ask what would have to be true for that to happen again, and whether anything in the plan makes it more likely.

If the loan works only in an average month, it does not work. Average months are an artifact of arithmetic, and nobody trades in one.

Also decide in advance what you would do at the first sign of trouble. Lenders have far more options before a missed payment than after one, and a conversation started early is about restructuring while a conversation started late is about default.

Common questions

Is a lower monthly payment a better deal?

Not on its own. A payment can be lowered by extending the term, which raises the total cost, or by deferring principal into a balloon, which moves the problem. Compare what actually reaches your account against everything that leaves it over the full life of the loan.

Should I take a fixed or a variable rate?

It depends on how much certainty your cash flow needs and how long the loan runs. A business with thin margins and a tight monthly cycle values predictability more than one with headroom.

Whatever you choose, learn the variable option's mechanics before rejecting it, since the reference, margin, reset frequency, and any cap decide how much movement you face.

Does paying off a term loan early save money?

On an amortising loan, yes, because interest accrues on the outstanding balance. Check the agreement for a prepayment charge first, since that is what removes the benefit. Products priced with a fixed fee rather than accruing interest behave differently and early repayment saves nothing.

How long should the term be?

As long as the working life of what you are financing, and no longer. That answer beats any rule of thumb about payment size, because it is the only one tied to why you are borrowing at all.

In this guide

  1. Term loans calculator: build a sheet that tests a paymentBuild your own term loans calculator in a spreadsheet: eight inputs, PMT and RATE to test a quoted payment, then place each charge and cost the offer.
  2. Term loans mistakes: nine errors from sizing the request to closing the fileNine term loan mistakes in the order they happen, from sizing the request through covenants, prepayment, refinancing and closing the lien file out.
  3. Lenders for term loans: what each institution is actually built to do wellTerm loan lenders sorted by what each institution type is built to do well, with named banks, credit unions and community lenders to compare.
  4. Term loans comparison: four things to normalise before offers mean anythingTerm loans comparison: the four things to normalise before two offers mean anything, a grid to run them through, and what decides a close result.
  5. 7 points on term loans rules that matterTerm loans rules live in your own stack of documents, not in a published code. A reading procedure: definitions first, then seven points before signing.
Filed underterm loans

More in Features

Latest from Practice Desk